Good forHistory buffs
Colonel E.B. Morgan — a native of Aurora and co-founder of the New York Times — built the inn in 1833, when travelers arrived by coach, canal boat, and rail. It sat on the eastern shore of Cayuga Lake, in a village that had already outlasted an Indigenous settlement, a Revolutionary War expedition, and the slow decline of canal-era commerce. In 2001, Wells College alumna Pleasant Rowland partnered with the college to renovate it. The courts fought over whether that renovation should happen. It did.
Quick facts
- ·The Aurora Inn (originally Aurora House) was built in 1833 by Colonel Edwin B. Morgan, an Aurora native and Cayuga Lake shipping/trade businessman. (Source: innsofaurora.com/history-of-the-aurora-inn, Wikipedia 'Aurora Inn'.) Note: Morgan's NYT role should be described as early investor/original shareholder, not 'co-founder' — see rejected facts.
- ·The completion of the Erie Canal turned Aurora into a shipping point moving agricultural products off Cayuga Lake into the broader canal network toward New York City and other markets, and during the 19th century the Aurora Inn served as an overnight destination for travelers arriving via stagecoach, canal boat, and rail. (Source: Wikipedia 'Aurora Inn': 'Aurora served as a port for shipping goods up Cayuga Lake and through the Erie Canal to New York City and other major markets' and 'During the 19th century, the Aurora Inn was an overnight destination for travelers who visited Aurora via stagecoach, canal boat and rail.') Note: the specific commodity list 'wool, grain, fruit, and pigs' is NOT supported by the cited sources — see rejected facts.
- ·A period newspaper account, published soon after the Inn's opening, praised its 'regularity, neatness and order exhibited everywhere' and its 'uninterrupted view of the water scenery of the most enchanting kind,' documenting the Inn's early reputation for hospitality during the canal-era travel boom. (Source: Wikipedia 'Aurora Inn', verbatim quoted text.)
- ·In the early 1840s, William D. Eagles purchased the Aurora Inn and engaged his uncle, former sea captain John Eagles, to manage it for him. (Source: innsofaurora.com/history-of-the-aurora-inn, exact quote: 'William D. Eagles purchased the inn and engaged his uncle, former sea captain John Eagles, to manage it for him.' Corroborated in part by Wikipedia 'Aurora Inn', which confirms the 1840s purchase by William D. Eagles and the Eagles family portraits.)
More archive
2 historical photographs.
Memories
Be the first to leave a memory at Aurora Inn.
Sign in to see memories your family has left at this place.
Editorial content compiled with AI assistance. Place details verified against public records.